Metacognition for orientation discrimination: effects of occipital lobe damage and training

Poster Presentation: Saturday, May 17, 2025, 8:30 am – 12:30 pm, Banyan Breezeway
Session: Plasticity and Learning: Clinical

Matt Cavanaugh1, Robbe Goris2, Elisha Merriam3, Krystel Huxlin1; 1Flaum Eye Institute, University of Rochester, Rochester, NY, USA, 2Center for Perceptual Systems, University of Texas at Austin, Austin, TX, USA, 3Laboratory of Brain and Cognition, National Institute of Mental Health, NIH, Bethesda, MD, USA

Occipital strokes damage early visual areas, causing a large visual deficit. Psychophysical training can restore multiple perceptual abilities within this deficit, including direction and orientation discrimination. Here, we assessed metacognitive capabilities at blind-field locations in which orientation discrimination was either restored following training or remained impaired, using a gamified task to collect confidence reports simultaneous with orientation discrimination thresholds in seven patients (4 male; age: 37-71 years; time since stroke: 6.4-25.7 months). Five patients trained on fine direction discrimination (FDD) within their blind-field; two trained on fine orientation discrimination (FOD). Blind-field performance was initially at chance on both tasks. After training, blind-field FDD improved in all FDD-trained participants, with thresholds nearing intact-field levels (blind-field: 17.8±19.4; intact-field: 2.2±1.2; paired t-test: p=0.15). FOD thresholds likewise improved in both FOD-trained patients (blind-field: 3.4deg and 7.9deg; intact-field: 1.56 deg and 0.4 deg). Three FDD-trained participants failed to recover FOD thresholds at trained, blind-field locations, performing at chance on the gamified task (percent correct: 56.5±7.6%), and indicating high confidence on 6.0±9.2% of trials. All remaining patients (two FDD-trained and two FOD-trained) attained significantly improved orientation thresholds (blind-field: 5.0±4.5 deg), reporting high confidence on 49.3±10.8% of trials. Confidence and performance data were then fit with a computational model (CASANDRE, Boundy-Singer et al., 2023) to calculate meta-uncertainty, summarizing the quality of the brain's confidence computation (the higher meta-uncertainty, the noisier the confidence computation). All blind-field locations exhibited low meta-uncertainty (impaired: 0.013±0.005; recovered: 0.48±0.56) indistinguishable from the intact-field (0.87±0.75; intact vs recovered paired t-test p=0.52; intact vs impaired paired t-test p=0.13). Our results show discrimination confidence tracks lawfully with orientation discrimination performance within retrained blind-fields of patients with early visual cortex damage. We conclude that the metacognitive system can correctly process activity from visual circuitry spared by occipital strokes, which supports recovered orientation perception.